The Dancing with the Stars ballroom has been rocked by a major behind-the-scenes power shift, as executives reportedly debate whether longtime judge Carrie Ann Inaba should step down from the panel. Following weeks of backlash and fan outrage over her controversial scoring and emotional critiques, an internal investigation by ABC has fueled speculation that big changes are on the horizon. But the most shocking twist yet? Insiders claim that none other than Bindi Irwin — beloved conservationist, TV personality, and former Mirrorball champion — is at the top of the replacement list.
According to multiple sources, network executives have spent the past several weeks quietly discussing how to refresh the judging lineup and restore harmony to the show’s fanbase. While Carrie Ann has been a cornerstone of DWTS since its early days, some producers reportedly feel it’s time for a “fresh energy” — someone who embodies warmth, positivity, and relatability. Enter Bindi Irwin, whose unforgettable Season 21 win and enduring popularity make her a natural fit for the role.
“Bindi represents everything Dancing with the Stars stands for — heart, growth, and connection,” one insider shared. “She knows the show inside and out, she’s beloved by viewers across generations, and she carries a grace that could really balance the panel.”
Fans have already begun weighing in online, and the reaction is a mix of nostalgia and cautious optimism. While some viewers say they can’t imagine the ballroom without Carrie Ann’s signature passion and fierce honesty, others are thrilled at the thought of Bindi’s return — this time in a role that celebrates her evolution from competitor to mentor. “If anyone deserves that seat, it’s her,” one fan commented. “Bindi’s spirit and kindness are exactly what this show needs right now.”
Behind the scenes, Carrie Ann’s fate reportedly remains undecided. ABC officials are said to be carefully reviewing the results of their internal evaluation, balancing loyalty to a long-standing figure against the need to keep the franchise fresh and drama-free. For Carrie Ann, the past few weeks have been emotionally draining, marked by harsh criticism, fan petitions, and intense scrutiny from both media and producers.
Still, those close to her insist she’s handling the speculation with dignity. “Carrie Ann loves the show — it’s been her home for nearly two decades,” a colleague shared. “If change comes, she’ll bow out gracefully. But make no mistake — she’s not going quietly.”
As for Bindi, sources say she has not yet confirmed or denied any talks with ABC. However, her recent social media activity — including cryptic posts about “new adventures” and “celebrating the beauty of second chances” — has only added fuel to the fire. Many fans believe these hints could signal a major television comeback.
For now, the ballroom is holding its breath. Will DWTS say goodbye to one of its most iconic judges and welcome a new face from the Irwin legacy? Or will Carrie Ann weather the storm and reclaim her spot with renewed purpose?
One thing’s certain — whether it’s the end of an era or the start of a new one, the heart of Dancing with the Stars is about to change forever.
