The Dancing With the Stars ballroom erupted in disbelief during the show’s much-anticipated Wicked Night episode — and it wasn’t because of the dazzling performances. Instead, chaos unfolded when Scott Hoying and Rylee Arnold were unexpectedly eliminated, despite earning one of the higher scores of the evening.
The crowd gasped as the results were read. Moments earlier, the duo had delivered a show-stopping routine that judges praised for its precision, creativity, and emotional storytelling. Fans were convinced they were safe — perhaps even headed toward the finals. But when their names appeared in the bottom, everything changed.
Viewers immediately took to social media, calling the outcome “a total travesty.” The outrage only grew when it was revealed that Andy Richter, who received the lowest score of the night, would remain in the competition. Many fans accused the show of favoring popularity over performance, turning what was once a dance competition into what they called a “popularity contest.”
One frustrated viewer wrote, “Scott and Rylee danced their hearts out — they didn’t deserve this. It should have been Andy. I’m sorry, but really?” Others flooded the comments with hashtags like #JusticeForScott and #DWTSRigged, sparking a digital firestorm that continued long after the show ended.
Inside sources hinted that even some contestants were shocked by the result, describing the backstage atmosphere as “tense” and “heartbroken.” According to reports, Rylee Arnold was seen holding back tears as her castmates rushed to comfort her after the elimination.
VIDEO:
Meanwhile, Scott Hoying — ever the professional — thanked his partner, the judges, and his fans with grace, saying, “This journey has been incredible. I came here to push myself, and I’m proud of what we created every single week.” His words only deepened fans’ admiration, making the loss feel even heavier.
The controversy has reignited a long-standing debate about the DWTS voting system — whether public votes should outweigh judges’ scores when the results seem to contradict performance quality. Many are now calling for ABC to review its format to restore viewer trust.
Across fan forums and discussion boards, the question continues to echo: Is talent still what keeps you in the competition — or has the ballroom lost its balance between skill and popularity?
As emotions simmer and speculation grows, one thing is certain — Wicked Night will go down as one of the most explosive and polarizing episodes in recent Dancing With the Stars history.
