In one of the most powerful moments of American Idol 2025, 18-year-old John Foster from Addis, Louisiana, stood on the Idol stage and delivered a performance that would leave an indelible mark on the season—and on everyone watching.
Foster’s original song, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” was written in memory of his late friends Maggie Dunn and Caroline Gill, two beloved young women tragically killed in a 2022 car accident. From the moment the first note rang out, Foster’s voice carried the raw grief, love, and aching beauty of that loss. It wasn’t just a song—it was a message from the heart, shared with the world.
But it was what came next that truly made this moment unforgettable.
After the performance, country superstar Jelly Roll—American Idol’s first-ever Artist in Residence—walked onstage. With the room hushed, he read a personal letter addressed to John. His voice trembled with emotion:
“John, your performance touched my soul. The depth of your emotion and the sincerity in your voice reminded me of why I fell in love with music in the first place.”
The silence in the studio was profound. Judges sat speechless, some visibly emotional. Jelly Roll continued:
“In a world where authenticity is rare, you stand out as a beacon of truth. Your ability to channel your pain into something beautiful is a testament to your strength and artistry. Watching you perform was not just witnessing a contestant on a show—it was experiencing a true artist sharing his heart with the world.”
It was a moment of artistic passing-of-the-torch—one musician recognizing something profound in another. And the world saw it too. Social media lit up with tributes to Foster’s bravery, to Jelly Roll’s grace, and to the reminder of what American Idol was built for: discovering voices that matter.
Carrie Underwood summed it up best, saying: “He’s bringing country back.” She praised Foster’s “gentle, traditional tone,” and his ability to “make people lean in and listen.” That kind of praise, coming from a country legend and Idol alum herself, carried weight.
This wasn’t just a performance. This was John Foster’s turning point.
Raised in small-town Louisiana, Foster has always carried himself with humility, quietly letting his music do the talking. What started as a tribute to lost friends became a national moment of healing and connection. His vulnerability, paired with a voice that feels like it was lifted from classic vinyl, brought a new sense of depth to this season of American Idol.
Thanks to Jelly Roll’s mentorship, Foster’s artistry has evolved into something that feels both timeless and urgent. Jelly’s role as Artist in Residence has brought more than just big names to the stage—it’s brought heart, honesty, and a commitment to storytelling through music.
And for Foster, this is just the beginning.
From singing for friends back home to moving millions across the country, John Foster’s journey is a powerful reminder of why music matters. His story, his voice, and his message will outlast the competition.
