The ballroom is still buzzing after Robert Irwin’s Dancing With the Stars debut — and now Derek Hough has broken his silence, sending shockwaves through the fanbase. “I’ve never seen something like this,” Derek admitted, his voice filled with awe, as he praised Robert’s first-ever performance under the glittering lights.
For Derek, a longtime judge and champion of the show, Robert’s debut carried echoes of history. He drew a striking comparison to the unforgettable season when Bindi Irwin, Robert’s sister, captured the world’s heart and ultimately won the Mirrorball. “He’s got that same potential,” Derek said, a remark that instantly lit up headlines and ignited debate across social media.
Yet Derek’s praise came with a caveat — one that sparked immediate controversy. While applauding Robert’s growth and stage presence, he noted that much of the magic was due to Witney Carson’s razor-sharp choreography and mentorship. It was a comment that fans didn’t take lightly.
Supporters rushed to defend Robert, insisting that his determination, heart, and natural charisma are what made his performance unforgettable. “Don’t reduce him to just good choreography,” one fan posted. “Robert is the reason we were glued to the screen.”
Others argued Derek wasn’t dismissing Robert at all, but simply highlighting the powerful partnership that defines success on DWTS. “Witney pushes her partners to greatness,” one viewer countered. “Recognizing her role doesn’t make Robert any less of a star.”
The split reaction has only added to the excitement of the season. For some, Derek’s remarks set the stage for Robert to prove himself even further, turning each performance into a chance to silence doubters and cement his place in the competition.
VIDEO:
Meanwhile, Robert himself has stayed humble, thanking Witney publicly and calling her “the best teacher I could ever ask for.” His gracious response has only deepened fan admiration, showing a maturity that echoes the grace of his late father, Steve Irwin.
Whether Derek’s words were a critique or a compliment in disguise, one thing is certain: Robert Irwin has become the name on everyone’s lips. With his blend of passion, charm, and resilience, his DWTS journey is no longer just a debut — it’s shaping up to be a season-defining phenomenon.
