With his signature cowboy hat and a heart full of Louisiana pride, 18-year-old John Foster turned Disney Night into his own personal showcase on American Idol. Delivering a vibrant and soulful rendition of “Almost There” from The Princess and the Frog, Foster lit up the stage with so much personality and charm that even judge Lionel Richie could barely get a word in over the crowd’s roaring applause.
During the May 11, 2025, episode—part of Idol’s first-ever two-night Disney extravaganza—Foster’s performance was more than just a tribute to his home state. It was a celebration of identity, perseverance, and sheer star power. Working with guest mentor Lin-Manuel Miranda ahead of the live show, Foster was encouraged to “lean into your inner rock star,” and from the moment he snapped his fingers and launched into the upbeat number, it was clear he took that advice to heart.
Watch his performance below:
Dressed in a gleaming gold suit jacket, Foster started off smooth and steady before unleashing his playful side, dancing across the stage with effortless charisma as the audience clapped and sang along. The energy in the room was electric—so much so that Richie, usually quick to offer feedback, had to pause until the cheers died down. “The crowd said it all for me,” he finally said with a smile.
Carrie Underwood praised Foster’s commitment to authenticity, noting that he brings a genuine sense of self to every song. Luke Bryan, meanwhile, couldn’t help but gush over Foster’s infectious stage presence, declaring with a grin, “Charisma, charisma, charisma. That’s why you’re almost there.”
Foster’s performance marked a major moment in Idol Season 23, as the top 7 contestants returned from emotional family trips to Disneyland to compete for a coveted spot in the top 5. The special Mother’s Day episode featured tributes to the women who raised them, with each song choice deeply tied to the contestants’ upbringings. As always, fans were given less than two hours to vote during the coast-to-coast live show, with host Ryan Seacrest announcing results by the end of the night.
For Foster, “Almost There” was more than a song—it was a mission statement. If he makes it to the top 3, he’ll be rewarded with a hometown visit, a moment he’s surely dreaming about. And judging by the way he lit up the American Idol stage, that dream might be closer than he thinks.
