As American Idol Season 23 speeds toward its grand finale, the spotlight isn’t just on the finalists—John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix—but also on the judging panel, especially newcomer Carrie Underwood.
Carrie stepped into the judging role this season, replacing Katy Perry, and reactions have been mixed. While her star power and vocal prowess are undeniable, some fans have questioned her comfort in the judge’s seat. Critics argue that she’s held back on delivering constructive feedback, often favoring kind words over critiques—possibly a reflection of her own Idol journey, where she once stood nervously before judges herself.
But is Carrie sticking around?
“We’re in a Good Place,” Says Idol Boss
In a recent interview with TVLine, Megan Michaels Wolflick, executive producer and showrunner of American Idol, shared some insight into what’s ahead for Season 24. When asked if Carrie, along with fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, will return, Megan remained hopeful.
“It’s still early,” she admitted, “but I think we’re in a really good place. I love this panel. I’m excited for them to crown their first winner together.”
That optimism suggests that Carrie’s return is very likely—but the final decision remains in her hands.
Megan also revealed that thousands of auditions are already pouring in for Season 24, a promising sign of strong momentum for the franchise. Even more impressive is the fact that live show viewership has steadily increased throughout the season—an impressive feat in today’s streaming-dominated world.
Carrie’s Learning Curve
From the start, Carrie has acknowledged the difficulty of stepping into the role of a critic. She confessed she’s been careful not to be too harsh, recalling how tough it was receiving feedback as a contestant. While fans appreciate her empathy, many hope she’ll find a stronger balance between encouragement and useful critique.
After all, this is American Idol, and growth through feedback is what has shaped so many stars. The current panel—while charismatic—has faced criticism for playing it too safe, with viewers noting the lack of deep, constructive comments from all three judges.
Still, Carrie’s presence on the show hasn’t gone unnoticed. Her own performances this season, like “How Great Thou Art” and “Alone,” have left audiences speechless and added a stunning vocal highlight to the season.
What Fans Want Next
As the finale approaches and one of the Top 3 will soon be crowned the next American Idol, the big question looms: Will Carrie Underwood return for Season 24?
From fans’ perspective, her return would be a win—as long as she steps into her full potential as a judge. With her talent, experience, and ability to connect with contestants, Carrie could become one of the most impactful voices on the panel. A little more edge, a little more honesty, and she’s golden.
And with the chemistry between her, Luke, and Lionel building each week, viewers may be looking at a judging trio that’s just getting started.
Stay Tuned…
For now, all eyes are on the three-hour finale, packed with superstar performances, including appearances by Jennifer Holliday, Patti LaBelle, Kirk Franklin, Goo Goo Dolls, Salt N Pepa, Jelly Roll, and more. Whether Carrie’s journey as a judge continues, one thing’s for sure: American Idol is closing out Season 23 on a high note.
