Carrie Underwood’s future on American Idol is looking increasingly uncertain after a season finale that drew more criticism than celebration — at least when it comes to her role as a judge.
During the climactic moment of Season 23, as Jamal Roberts was crowned the winner, fans were quick to point out Carrie’s noticeably subdued reaction. While Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan stood in ovation, Underwood remained seated, an image that quickly made the rounds online and sparked backlash. Her reserved demeanor — combined with a pointed critique that Roberts “needed to be more animated” — struck many viewers as cold and dismissive, especially given Roberts’ emotional and widely praised performances throughout the season.
In the days that followed, Underwood’s silence only added to the speculation. She retreated from the spotlight, returning to her private estate outside Nashville. When pressed about whether she would return for Season 24, her response — “I don’t know. There’s a lot to consider.” — was far from reassuring.
Behind-the-scenes tensions?
According to insiders, ABC may have had reservations about Underwood from the start. While she offered major star power and a strong country music pedigree, some producers reportedly questioned her on-air chemistry and overall energy. Her comments, especially toward the end of the season, were described as “flat” by fans online — and her distance during emotional contestant moments only reinforced that perception.
Coupled with social media backlash and waning audience connection, the network is now said to be seriously weighing its options for next season’s panel.
Who Could Replace Carrie?
If Underwood does exit, two massive names have surged to the top of fan and industry wish lists:
1. Katy Perry – The Comeback Queen
After leaving the show following Season 22, Katy Perry’s absence was deeply felt by the Idol fan base. Known for her vibrant personality, genuine investment in contestants, and bold fashion choices, Perry helped shape the show’s modern identity. A return would likely reignite chemistry with Richie and Bryan — and restore the balance many felt was off this season.
2. Kelly Clarkson – The Original Idol Returns
Kelly Clarkson isn’t just an American Idol winner — she is Idol to many. Her warmth, authenticity, and sharp musical instincts have made her a standout coach on The Voice and a beloved host of The Kelly Clarkson Show. If she joined the judges’ table, it would be a true full-circle moment, bridging Idol’s history with its future and breathing new life into the format.
As American Idol looks to Season 24, producers may have a tough decision ahead: stick with a country icon who faced heavy criticism, or shake things up by bringing back a familiar favorite or welcoming a beloved Idol alum. One thing’s clear — fans are watching closely, and they want heart, connection, and chemistry from their judges. Whether Carrie Underwood still fits that bill remains to be seen.
