When John Foster and Breanna Nix reunited in Nashville, they didn’t just catch up — they delivered a musical moment fans won’t soon forget. The American Idol Season 23 finalists joined forces for an intimate rendition of Carrie Underwood and Randy Travis’ classic duet, “I Told You So,” and gave fans a taste of the magic via Instagram.
Captured in a simple, cozy setting, the clip showed Foster on guitar and the two trading heartfelt verses with ease. Nix captioned the video, “Singing with @officialjohnfoster 🔥 Let us know how it sounds to you… Should we finish the rest?” The chemistry was instant, the harmonies rich, and the response? Overwhelming.
Fans filled the comments with pleas for a full version. “Absolutely finish it!! It sounds fantastic! Best duet I’ve heard in a long time!” one wrote. Even Foster’s girlfriend, Brooklyn Bourque, showed her love by sharing the video to her Instagram Story — further proof this duet struck a chord far and wide.
Their reunion came during a packed week in Nashville for CMA Fest, where the two Idol standouts took the stage together on June 4 alongside fellow alumni. Season 23 winner Jamal Roberts also joined the celebration, making it a true family affair for fans of the show.
But the biggest milestone of the week came when both Foster and Nix made their official debuts at the Grand Ole Opry — a dream moment for any country artist.
“The first time I went to the Opry, I fought back tears,” Foster wrote on Instagram. “There is no more significant place to my passion than the Grand Ole Opry. This has been my #1 dream ever since I started music — and now it’s coming true.”
For Nix, the sentiment was just as powerful: “It was such a privilege and honor to sing at the @opry,” she shared. “A true bucket list moment.”
From a viral duet to a Grand Ole Opry debut, Foster and Nix proved once again why they stole America’s hearts on Idol. And judging by the response to their clip, fans are hoping this reunion was just the beginning.
