Dancing With the Stars Season 35 delivered one of its most surprising eliminations on Tuesday, November 17, when a leading contender was sent home just one week before the highly anticipated finale. Actor Harry Shum Jr. and professional partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated despite earning perfect scores for both of their performances. Their unexpected departure stunned viewers and fellow contestants, particularly because the pair had established themselves among the strongest competitors of the season. The emotional outcome also brought renewed attention to judge Carrie Ann Inaba’s enthusiastic praise for their remarkable performances.
The shocking elimination took place during the Season 35 semifinals, when six remaining celebrity contestants and their professional partners competed for just five positions in the finale. Unlike previous themed episodes, the semifinals allowed each couple to perform two different routines, including one ballroom dance and one Latin dance. The demanding format gave contestants an opportunity to showcase their versatility while demonstrating the progress they had made throughout the competition.
Heading into the evening, several couples were considered strong contenders for the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy. Olympic figure skater Amber Glenn and partner Pasha Pashkov had consistently impressed the judges, while Paralympic athlete Ezra Frech and professional dancer Daniella Karagach had earned recognition for their remarkable improvement. However, Shum and Johnson were also among the competition’s strongest performers, having delivered memorable routines and impressive technical performances throughout the season.
Shum, who is widely recognized for his roles in Glee and Grey’s Anatomy, entered the competition with experience in dance and entertainment. His professional background helped him develop strong coordination, musical awareness, and stage presence, but ballroom dancing introduced new technical challenges. Working alongside Johnson, he continued refining his technique while adapting to unfamiliar dance styles. Their partnership became one of the season’s most recognizable combinations, with viewers following their progress toward the finale.
For their first semifinal performance, Shum and Johnson delivered a powerful paso doble that immediately impressed the judging panel. The dramatic routine showcased sharp movements, precise timing, and the intensity associated with the traditional Latin dance. Judge Derek Hough enthusiastically praised the performance, while Bruno Tonioli admired the dancers’ strong technique and commanding presence. Carrie Ann Inaba was particularly impressed, describing their routine as one of the season’s outstanding paso doble performances.
The judges rewarded Shum and Johnson with a perfect score of 30 out of 30, placing them among the highest-scoring couples of the evening. Their achievement demonstrated the technical progress they had made during their time together and reinforced their position as serious championship contenders. However, the semifinals required a second performance, meaning they still needed to deliver another impressive routine before learning whether they had secured a place in the finale.
For their second dance, Shum and Johnson performed a quickstep to “Valerie” by Mark Ronson featuring Amy Winehouse. The fast-paced routine required precise footwork, strong coordination, and constant movement across the ballroom floor. The couple successfully combined technical accuracy with an energetic presentation, earning another enthusiastic reaction from the judges. Their performance demonstrated that they could handle contrasting dance styles while maintaining the level of quality expected from potential finalists.
Carrie Ann Inaba appeared particularly impressed by the quickstep, admitting that the routine had left her struggling to find words. She praised Shum’s development as a ballroom dancer, especially his ability to lead his partner confidently throughout the performance. Derek Hough also celebrated the routine, suggesting that it represented the kind of dancing worthy of a place in the finale. Tonioli agreed with the positive assessment, praising the couple’s technical execution and overall presentation.
The judges awarded Shum and Johnson another perfect score, giving them an outstanding combined total of 60 out of 60 points. The achievement placed them in a tie for the highest score of the night with Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov, who also delivered two flawless performances. With such strong results, Shum and Johnson appeared to be in an excellent position to advance, making the final elimination announcement even more unexpected.
Other contestants also delivered impressive routines during the semifinals. Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas earned 59 out of 60 points, while Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach finished with 57. Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik received 55 points, and Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold ended the evening with 48. Although the judges’ scores reflected differences in technical performance, the competition’s format also required audience votes to determine which couples would remain.
The final results demonstrated how unpredictable the competition could become when viewer voting was combined with the judges’ scores. Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold, who finished at the bottom of the judges’ leaderboard, were among the first couples announced as safe. Amber Glenn, Tatyana Ali, and Maura Higgins also secured positions in the finale. That left Shum and Johnson standing alongside Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach as the final two couples awaiting the announcement.
When the results were revealed, Shum and Johnson were eliminated, bringing their remarkable journey to an unexpected conclusion. Their departure was especially surprising because they had delivered two perfect performances and finished tied for first place on the judges’ leaderboard. Although the judges had expressed extraordinary admiration for their routines, the combined voting results were not enough to keep them in the competition. Their elimination illustrated that outstanding technical scores alone do not guarantee advancement on Dancing With the Stars.
With Shum and Johnson eliminated, five couples will compete in the Season 35 finale on Tuesday, November 24. Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov, Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach, Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas, Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik, and Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold will return for one final opportunity to win the Mirrorball Trophy. The unexpected semifinal results have made the championship race particularly difficult to predict, as the remaining contestants prepare for their final performances. For Shum and Johnson, their elimination may have ended their championship hopes, but their two perfect scores and memorable partnership remain among the standout achievements of Season 35.





