Three finalists are left standing in the race to become the next American Idol, but the biggest headlines following the Top 5 Disney-themed episode weren’t about the contestants — they were about Carrie Underwood.
During the May 12 live show, Underwood stunned in a bold, Rapunzel-inspired purple gown, complete with floral embroidery, silver stilettos, and long, flowing blonde hair that cascaded to her ankles. While the whimsical look lit up Instagram with praise, her commentary during the show lit a fuse online — and not in a good way.
Viewers accused Underwood of showing favoritism and being overly harsh in her critiques, particularly when it came to fan-favorite Jamal Roberts. While she acknowledged Jamal’s vocal talent, she criticized him for not moving around more during his performance — a comment that immediately sparked backlash.
“Get rid of her. Her bias is showing,” one viewer posted. Another added, “I wish we could vote her off. It’s cringe to watch her play favorites.” Supporters of Jamal were especially vocal, with one fan writing, “She critiques Jamal for standing still, but praises John Foster for doing the exact same thing? That’s not fair.” The sentiment was echoed widely across social media, with comments like “She definitely didn’t like Jamal” and “You bring fake energy — don’t come back next year.”
Some viewers even suggested potential replacements: “Jelly Roll pleaseeee replace her.”
However, the reaction wasn’t one-sided. Others defended Underwood’s role, stating that she was simply doing her job as a judge. “You’re still going to get criticized, so do whatever you want 💫 ❤️🔥😸,” one fan posted. Another commented, “Loved you as a judge this year — people don’t realize you were dressed as Rapunzel tonight!” There were also calls of support: “Carrie, I enjoyed watching you this season. Hope you come back next year!”
Despite the heated discourse, the competition continued, and the Top 3 finalists were announced. Advancing to the finale are Jamal Roberts, John Foster, and Breanna Nix. Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were eliminated. Each remaining contestant delivered memorable performances: Jamal wowed with “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” and “Beauty and the Beast,” John charmed with “The Bare Necessities” and “Rainbow Connection,” while Breanna impressed with “This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)” and “You’ll Be in My Heart.”
While the judges offered positive feedback to the finalists heading into the finale on May 18, Underwood’s role on the panel remained a lightning rod for controversy.
This isn’t the first time Carrie’s appearance has sparked debate. Back in March 2025, she drew attention on Instagram for a twirling video in a dramatic denim-inspired outfit with a massive bow, black-and-white ruffled skirt, and sky-high heels. Fans were quick to shift focus from the fashion to her face, speculating about possible cosmetic enhancements. “What did she do to her lips?” and “Too much filler — she was beautiful before,” some remarked. Others were more supportive, saying, “She’s beautiful. Such a sweet spirit!” and “Totally fit — she looks incredible!”
Still, Underwood has remained confident and unapologetic in her style choices, fully embracing the spotlight whether she’s met with applause or critique.
Meanwhile, fellow country superstar Miranda Lambert also made headlines during the May 4 episode when she performed “Kerosene” as a guest mentor. The reactions were split. Some praised the performance, while others called out a lack of energy. “She was giving bare minimum stage presence — and I love that for her,” one viewer said. “Plugged my ears the whole time. Can’t stand her!” another wrote. Some even speculated about a tense moment, wondering, “Why did Carrie look so bored during Miranda’s set?”
Yet again, fans turned their attention to Lambert’s appearance, with several praising her weight loss and style. “She looked amazing,” one fan said, while detractors branded her an “energy drainer.”
As American Idol heads into its highly anticipated finale, the focus remains split between the talent on stage and the drama surrounding the judges. And whether she’s beloved or blasted, Carrie Underwood remains front and center.
