merican Idol Season 23’s Disney and Mother’s Day tribute night ended with an emotional twist — and no shortage of controversy. Despite delivering two powerhouse performances — “How Far I’ll Go” from Moana and “Home” from The Wiz — fan-favorite Gabby Samone was eliminated, along with fellow contestant Mattie Pruitt. The Top 5 advancing to the finale are Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, Slater Nalley, and Thunderstorm Artis.
Gabby’s exit shocked fans and ignited a flurry of backlash online. While her soaring vocals and commanding stage presence had many predicting a finale spot — or even a win — some viewers believe her departure once again highlights a long-standing pattern on Idol: the perceived advantage of country-influenced artists.
Following the episode, Gabby remained gracious and grateful in an Instagram post:
“Thank you all so much for the love and support!!! I am soo grateful to have made it this far! I love you all! Please continue to support my friends on their journey! This was an amazing experience!! THIS IS ONLY THE BEGINNING!! #TEAMGABBY”
Fans, however, weren’t as diplomatic. Many expressed frustration that country-adjacent singers appeared to be dominating the voting results. One comment read:
“Here we go again — COUNTRY SINGERS surpassing true talent. I’m not watching it anymore!!!!!”
Another said:
“So frustrating. Same story every year. Gabby should have won and Jamal been the runner-up.”
Although John Foster is the most clearly country-leaning contestant, some have lumped Breanna Nix and Slater Nalley into the same category — despite Breanna’s roots in gospel and Christian music and Slater’s more singer-songwriter vibe. Meanwhile, Jamal Roberts and Thunderstorm Artis bring R&B, gospel, and soul to the table — a reminder that musical styles on Idol are often more nuanced than public perception allows.
Still, the outrage reflects deeper conversations fans have had for years about genre preference and voting dynamics. It’s not the first time a standout vocalist has been eliminated while more genre-popular artists advanced. However, as seen with past winners like Iam Tongi and Abi Carter, it’s also clear that non-country artists can win when fanbases mobilize.
Gabby’s elimination was undeniably a tough blow — but it doesn’t diminish her impact this season. Her performances left an impression, and her future in music looks promising. Meanwhile, as the competition narrows, the remaining five will battle it out in the finale, each bringing their own sound, story, and shot at the crown.
