18-year-old John Foster is proving week after week that he’s a force to be reckoned with on American Idol. After securing a spot in the Top 8 with his soulful cover of Bonnie Raitt’s “Something to Talk About,” Foster took to the stage again to battle for a place in the Top 7—and this time, he brought a performance full of heart and raw emotion.
As part of the Judges’ Song Contest, the contestants were given a special twist: each judge picked a song for the contestants to perform, but they had no idea who had chosen what. For Foster, the options were “Two Dozen Roses,” “I Cross My Heart,” and “Crazy.” He chose George Strait’s “I Cross My Heart,” a touching tribute to his girlfriend Brooklyn, whom he’s been dating for a year. Carrie Underwood, who had picked the song for him, couldn’t have been prouder of the choice.
Brooklyn, watching from the audience, was quick to gush over Foster’s heartfelt performance. Underwood, the queen of country ballads, was equally impressed, calling the performance “absolutely perfect” and praising Foster for making it feel “genuine” and “comfortable.”
Luke Bryan also chimed in, adding, “It was the perfect song for you… You’re singing better and better every week.” Clearly, Foster’s growth throughout the competition has been nothing short of remarkable.
A Special Connection with Carrie Underwood
Foster’s bond with Underwood has been a highlight of his Idol journey. After performing “I Told You So,” a song Underwood originally sang with Randy Travis on American Idol years ago, Foster dedicated his performance to her. Underwood was visibly touched and reflected on Foster’s growth over the course of the competition.
“He’s so sweet and fresh-faced,” she told People. “Week to week, we’ve watched him progress so much. He’s probably the one that has grown the most since he’s been here.”
Underwood, known for her maternal side, admitted that she felt a special connection to Foster. “I feel like he kind of reminds me of my oldest son,” she shared. “When he’s singing to me, I kind of feel like a proud mom. He’s very good.”
Foster’s Heartfelt Tribute to Underwood
In a touching moment of his own, Foster posted on Facebook, expressing his gratitude for the opportunity to perform in front of one of his idols. “It was such an honor to pay tribute to the incredible Carrie Underwood,” he wrote. “She’s been my voice on the judge’s panel, and I hope that my performance last night gave her the respect that she deserves.”
As Foster continues his American Idol journey, it’s clear that his connection with Underwood—and his unwavering commitment to his craft—are propelling him forward. With each performance, he’s not only winning over the judges but also the hearts of viewers everywhere.
Will John Foster make it to the Top 7? His growing fanbase, fueled by his passion and authentic performances, is rooting for him every step of the way.
