John Foster may have charmed the American Idol judges with a heartfelt taste of home, but it’s his unmistakable voice that continues to carry him through the competition, week after week. The Louisiana native’s standout Top 12 performance of Randy Travis’ “I Told You So” even had judge Carrie Underwood bursting with pride. As the competition narrows, every performance carries more weight—and Foster once again proved why he’s a fan favorite with his latest rendition of a Bonnie Raitt classic.
A Dazzling Performance on Ladies’ Night
For Ladies’ Night on American Idol, Foster selected Bonnie Raitt’s 1991 Grammy-winning hit, “Something to Talk About.” The themed episode paid tribute to iconic women in music and featured country star Miranda Lambert as mentor to the Top 10. Lambert, who also celebrated the 20th anniversary of her breakout hit “Kerosene,” coached contestants on how to channel the emotion and power of these legendary female artists.
Foster brought his trademark traditional country flair and warm vocals to the Raitt classic, delivering a performance that was both playful and commanding. As one of Season 23’s frontrunners, he’s carved out a lane for himself with a blend of sincerity, grit, and old-school charm.
From Butcher Shop to Big Stage
Foster’s journey is rooted deeply in his Louisiana heritage. He first caught the judges’ attention not only with his voice but also by hauling in coolers of homemade Cajun food during his audition—a gesture that earned smiles and full stomachs.
That same food comes from Benoit’s Country Meat Block, a family-owned butcher shop founded by Foster’s grandparents in 1982. Located in Addis, just outside Baton Rouge, the shop has become a local staple.
“To have those judges appreciate that and enjoy it meant a lot—not just to John Foster, but to myself and our whole family,” said his father, John “Buddy” Foster Benoit Jr., in an interview with local media.
Setting the Record Straight
With rising fame often comes speculation, and Foster recently addressed some false rumors circulating online. In a Facebook post, he cleared up persistent claims about industry connections and record deals.
“I’m not related to Dwight Yoakam, nor am I currently signed under any record label,” he wrote. “If you see something about me that’s not from my page (with the blue checkmark), there’s a chance that it may not be true!”
The post was a reminder that, despite his growing popularity, Foster remains grounded and transparent—a trait that’s endeared him even further to fans across the country.
