When John Foster takes the stage, it’s not just a performance—it’s a visceral experience. His rendition of George Jones’ If Drinkin’ Don’t Kill Me (Her Memory Will) on American Idol 2025 is a masterclass in vulnerability, pouring raw emotion into every word. Foster’s steady, soulful baritone captures the aching pain and quiet regret of the song, and with each note, you feel the weight of his sorrow. It’s clear: he’s not just singing a classic—he’s living it.
From the very first note, Foster’s voice is a steady force, but it’s the depth he brings to each line that makes the performance unforgettable. He doesn’t rush. Every verse feels like a moment in time, allowing the pain to breathe, to settle into the hearts of the audience. As the song progresses, the strain in his voice becomes palpable—a delicate crack that makes the emotions even more real.
But it’s not just his vocal performance that stands out. Foster manages to breathe new life into this classic country hit, making it feel fresh without losing the roots of its original spirit. He stays true to the timeless soul of the song, while adding his own unique spin that makes it feel simultaneously nostalgic and current. His interpretation is a perfect blend of tradition and modernity, making it easy for fans both old and new to connect with the performance.
Foster’s vocal control throughout the song is nothing short of impressive. He navigates the emotional highs and lows with effortless precision, never over-singing but always allowing the emotion to flow naturally. This restraint, this quiet power, is what makes his rendition of If Drinkin’ Don’t Kill Me feel so deeply personal and impactful. Every note he sings feels intentional, every phrase a window into his heart.
A Moment for Brooklyn: John Foster’s Heartfelt Love Song
Monday night also brought the return of the fun Judges’ Song Contest round, where the Top 8 of American Idol 2025 fought to secure their place in the competition. This time, the contestants picked from songs chosen by the judges, with the winner getting the power to save a bottom-two contestant. John Foster, however, didn’t need any saving. His connection to the audience was already sealed, particularly with his stunning performance of I Cross My Heart by George Strait.
The song selection was no accident. “George Strait is my biggest influence in music,” Foster shared, his voice filled with reverence. “I’ve listened to him ever since I came out the womb.” And with his girlfriend Brooklyn sitting in the audience, it was clear this performance was personal. The 18-year-old country singer poured his heart into every line, delivering the song with effortless charm and sincerity.
His stage presence, as always, was magnetic. There was a calm confidence in the way he held the mic, and as he sang the final line—“you’ll never find a love as true as mine”—the camera panned to Brooklyn, who lit up with pride. Their eyes locked, and she jumped to her feet, clearly moved by the moment they were sharing. It wasn’t just a performance; it was an intimate declaration of love. Ryan Seacrest captured the magic, asking Brooklyn how she felt, to which she gushed, “I don’t even know. It’s so good.”
Judges and Fans Take Notice
The judges were equally impressed. Carrie Underwood, who had picked the song, called it “absolutely perfect” and praised it as one of Foster’s best performances to date. Luke Bryan, who had once questioned whether Foster could even sing well enough, had nothing but praise now. “You’re singing better and better every week,” Bryan said, reflecting on Foster’s transformation throughout the competition.
Lionel Richie, always quick with a joke, teased Foster about not being a fan of Willie Nelson, to which Foster insisted that Nelson is, in fact, one of his favorites. Richie, all smiles, called Foster “amazing.”
Moving On Up: A Bright Future Ahead
Foster’s performance helped him secure a spot in the Top 7, with the bottom two contestants being Mattie Pruitt and Josh King. The judges, with their tie-breaking votes, sent Mattie through to the next round.
As Foster’s fanbase continues to grow, he’s been making waves across social media platforms. It’s clear now that he’s a strong contender, with many fans speculating that it’ll come down to him and Jamal Roberts for the crown. Speaking of Jamal, his performance of I Believe by Fantasia was equally powerful, despite the questionable song choice. Thunderstorm Artis, for his part, was also a standout with a heartfelt rendition of Faithfully by Journey, dedicated to his wife.
But it’s John Foster who continues to prove that, week after week, his consistency and authenticity are what set him apart. With each performance, he’s proving that his journey is just beginning—and if there’s one thing for certain, it’s that we’ll be hearing a lot more from this rising star
