Carrie Underwood’s latest Sunday Night Football opening has sparked a wave of discussion among NFL fans, with some viewers now calling for NBC to consider a major change to the long-running tradition.
The country superstar recently introduced a new version of the opening featuring a rock-inspired take on Joan Jett’s “I Hate Myself for Loving You,” giving the familiar football introduction a noticeably different sound.
While Underwood’s powerful vocals remain at the center of the performance, the musical change has divided viewers. Some fans praised the fresh direction, while others said they preferred the style of previous openings.
The reaction has become particularly noticeable on social media, where viewers have shared strong opinions about whether the new version works for one of the NFL’s biggest weekly broadcasts.
One fan post reportedly attracted more than 300,000 views, demonstrating just how much attention the opening has received. The response has fueled a broader conversation about whether the segment should remain with Underwood or eventually be handed to another major performer.
Some fans have even suggested replacing Underwood with another A-list star. Those calls appear to reflect frustration with the new arrangement rather than a confirmed plan by NBC to make a change.
Underwood has been closely associated with Sunday Night Football for years, making her voice part of the identity of the broadcast. She first took over the opening in 2013 and has continued performing it through multiple versions and musical arrangements.
The latest change is therefore more than simply a new song choice. It represents another attempt to refresh a segment that millions of football viewers see at the beginning of the week’s biggest NFL matchup.
The debate also shows how difficult it can be to change an established television tradition. Even when a performer brings a new interpretation, longtime viewers may compare it with versions they have heard for years.
For now, there is no confirmed indication that NBC plans to replace Underwood. The online calls remain fan reactions, while Underwood continues in the role.
Whether viewers eventually warm to the new rock-oriented approach or continue asking for a different voice will be one of the more interesting conversations surrounding the Sunday Night Football opening this season.
Compiled with various sources.
