Season 23 of American Idol closed with a monumental moment: Jamal Roberts was crowned the winner during a history-making finale on May 18, while Carrie Underwood made her debut as a judge — two decades after she herself won Season 4 in 2005. With the confetti barely settled and fans already looking ahead, the question now is: Will Carrie return for Season 24?
Carrie Underwood’s Full-Circle Moment
Carrie’s first season behind the judging table marked a symbolic turning point for the show. After Katy Perry’s departure, producers brought in Carrie not just for her star power but for the rich legacy she carries as arguably American Idol’s most successful winner. Reflecting on the experience, Carrie told Good Morning America:
“I mean, it feels like home. There are so many people that still work on the show who were there when I was a contestant.”
She also promised to bring honesty and heart:
“I can’t lie, I just can’t, you can tell. I feel like I’ll be very honest but hopefully inspiring.”
What the Producers Are Saying
While American Idol has confirmed a Season 24 renewal, no official announcement has been made about the returning judges. Executive producer Megan Michaels Wolflick praised Carrie’s debut, calling it both nostalgic and impactful:
“She really had to carve out her own role. She was stepping into the shoes of a former judge, but she needed to be her own person — and she definitely did that.”
Wolflick also acknowledged Carrie’s ability to give thoughtful, constructive criticism — something she says the show needs.
When asked directly whether Carrie would return next season, Wolflick remained cautious:
“It’s early days still… The momentum is coming, but we’ll have to stay tuned.”
Fans and Ratings: A Mixed Response
Carrie’s presence was a hit with many viewers, and ratings jumped to over 5 million during the finale. However, there’s been some online chatter — with a vocal minority of fans calling for her to be replaced, citing her delivery or style of critique. Still, most fans and critics agree that her honesty, experience, and emotional connection to the show added a valuable perspective.
What’s Next?
Thousands of auditions for Season 24 are already pouring in, and the Idol machine is in motion. Given Carrie’s strong debut and the show’s successful ratings bump, it’s likely that producers will push for her return, assuming scheduling and interest align.
As Wolflick put it:
“I love our panel. I think we’re in a good place. They’re all passionate about the show.”
Bottom Line
Carrie Underwood’s return as a judge on Season 24 of American Idol is very possible — but not officially confirmed yet. With fan buzz, producer praise, and solid ratings behind her, she’s in a strong position to come back. But for now, all we can do is stay tuned for that official Season 24 judges announcement in the coming months.
