The Season 23 finale of American Idol ended in high drama as Jamal Roberts was officially crowned the winner on Sunday, May 18, after a night of performances, star appearances, and more than 26 million viewer votes.
John Foster, the 18-year-old country singer from Addis, Louisiana, finished as runner-up, but fans were quick to rally behind him, expressing pride and anticipation for his future.
During the tense final moments of the show, host Ryan Seacrest stood between the final two contestants, preparing to read the result card from the nationwide vote. Seacrest, known for his dramatic pauses, seemed to inadvertently allow a glimpse of the card to Foster, who reportedly glanced at it before the name was announced.
“John Foster fully just saw the American Idol results 4 seconds before Seacrest announced it,” one viewer wrote on X (formerly Twitter). Another added, “It looked like John Foster saw the envelope!” A third commenter suggested, “Ryan needs to be facing the contestants rather than next to them when announcing results.”
Despite the momentary awkwardness, the focus quickly shifted to the incredible talent of both finalists. The three-hour finale featured emotional final performances from Jamal and John, while Breanna Nix, who finished in third, was eliminated after the first voting round of the night.
What Do the Winner and Runner-Up Get?
While the American Idol title comes with national recognition, there are also tangible rewards.
- Jamal Roberts, as the winner, is expected to receive:
- A recording contract with 19 Recordings, the label partnered with American Idol
- A cash prize of $125,000
- An advance of up to $100,000 for a debut album
- Additional funds to cover production and marketing costs
- John Foster, as the runner-up, is also entitled to a recording contract, albeit with a smaller advance than the winner. Historically, runner-ups often receive:
- An advance of up to $50,000–$75,000
- Opportunities to release music under 19 Recordings or affiliated labels
- Access to promotional support and potential tour partnerships
In recent years, Idol has also provided single deals to Top 5 or Top 7 contestants. For Season 23, all Top 7 finalists released original singles ahead of the finale, a major opportunity for early career momentum.
John Foster’s Future Looks Bright
Despite not taking home the title, John Foster’s fans were quick to praise his run on the show and his poised, heartfelt performances throughout the season.
“Congratulations to John Foster! We think you’re a great American and we love your music,” one fan posted. Another wrote, “So proud of John Foster even though he didn’t win. Definitely made Addis, Louisiana, and all of West Baton Rouge proud.”
With a devoted fanbase, a record deal likely in hand, and widespread visibility, John Foster’s music career is just beginning — and many believe his best moments are still ahead.
