As American Idol Season 23 wraps up, there’s been growing curiosity about the future of the judges’ panel, particularly after a season filled with high ratings, strong performances, and plenty of controversy. Executive producer Megan Michaels Wolflick has broken her silence on what’s ahead and offered some insight into what viewers can expect.
Carrie Underwood, who replaced Katy Perry this season, stirred major buzz. While many welcomed her return to the Idol stage—this time as a judge instead of a contestant—others criticized her judging style, particularly after her blunt critique of fan-favorite Jamal Roberts. Some fans accused her of being too harsh and inconsistent, while others saw her honesty as refreshing in a panel that often leans heavily toward praise.
Despite the backlash, the numbers don’t lie. The ratings were among the best the show has seen in recent years, with millions tuning in week after week. Megan Michaels Wolflick acknowledged this, stating that Carrie has “done more than they could have ever hoped” and calling her an asset to the show. While she stopped short of confirming the full panel’s return, she emphasized that it’s “early days” but that she loves the current lineup and feels “we’re in a good place.”
That optimism suggests that Carrie, along with Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, will likely be asked back. Whether all three choose to return remains uncertain, especially with Carrie reportedly having mixed feelings about some of the criticism she’s received. Still, the show’s resurgence in popularity, combined with her influence as a former winner and major country star, makes her return seem probable.
Meanwhile, the door might be opening wider for Jelly Roll, who joined this season as the show’s first-ever Artist in Residence. His behind-the-scenes mentorship and on-air appearances have won over fans and producers alike. Megan described having him on the show as a “dream,” and while nothing is official yet, many are already speculating that he could take on a larger role next season—possibly even as a fourth judge or recurring mentor.
For now, all eyes are on the May 18 finale, when either Breanna Nix, Jamal Roberts, or Slater Nalley will be crowned the next American Idol. After that, producers will turn their attention to casting and planning for Season 24. One thing is clear: the show isn’t going anywhere, and fans can expect more big announcements soon.
