The competition on American Idol Season 23 is reaching a fever pitch as the top 8 contestants battle for a coveted spot in the top 6. With the pressure mounting, each performance carries more weight, and this week’s eliminations have already shaken fans — Platinum Ticket holders Kolbi Jordan and Canaan James Hill were sent home, narrowing the field even further.
One of the standout moments of the night came from Jamal Roberts, who delivered a bold performance of Carrie Underwood’s hit “Undo It.” Dressed in all black with his signature cowboy hat, Roberts brought power, range, and soul to the stage — impressing not only the judges but Underwood herself, who was seated just feet away.
This week’s “Ladies Night” theme celebrated iconic women in music, with country superstar Miranda Lambert serving as guest judge. Lambert performed her song “Kerosene” in honor of its 20th anniversary and worked closely with contestants, helping them connect more deeply with their chosen songs. She coached Jamal to stay true to his style while honoring Underwood’s original — a balance he delivered with ease.
Although there was a small stumble early on when Jamal appeared to miss a couple of lyrics, he quickly recovered. Carrie Underwood brushed off the slip, saying, “Who cares?” and made it clear she loved his version. In a fun moment after the performance, she even put on his hat — a sign of her approval.
Judge Lionel Richie summed it up best: “Mesmerizing.” Roberts’ ability to captivate an audience, even during a tough theme week, shows why he’s earned his place in the top 8 — and why fans will be watching closely when the top 6 is revealed on Monday night, May 5.
