Jamal Roberts’ performance of “I Believe” on the May 5 “Judges’ Song Contest” episode was not just a standout moment of American Idol Season 23 — it was a defining one. Singing the Fantasia classic on the same day his daughter, Gianna Grace Roberts, was born, Roberts infused every note with personal meaning, emotion, and spiritual weight.
His decision to keep her birth a secret until the live show made the performance even more powerful — a love letter to his newborn and a moment that resonated deeply with fans and judges alike.
At 27, Jamal is no stranger to balancing real-life responsibilities with his musical dreams. As a PE teacher and father of three, he’s carried those life experiences into every song, giving his performances a maturity and emotional texture that set him apart. Choosing “I Believe” — a vocally demanding anthem of hope — wasn’t just a musical decision; it was a declaration of faith in his journey, in his role as a father, and in the future he’s trying to build.
The judges were visibly moved, with Lionel Richie (who selected the song) calling it “the perfect choice,” and admitting it brought him to tears. Carrie Underwood, who was behind the Stevie Wonder option, praised Lionel’s pick and encouraged Jamal to sing “Lately” eventually. Luke Bryan echoed the sentiment, pointing to the raw emotion Jamal brought to the moment.
His voice — full of grit, soul, and gospel roots — soared through the lyrics, culminating in a near-breakdown that made it clear: this wasn’t just a performance. It was a spiritual release, and one of the most unforgettable Idol moments of the season.
