John Foster, the 18-year-old country standout from Addis, Louisiana, continued his impressive run on American Idol Monday night, captivating both judges and viewers during the Top 5 performances of Season 23’s Disney-themed episode. With the stakes higher than ever and only three spots available in next week’s finale, Foster embraced the challenge of performing two songs from the Disney catalog—and delivered in a way only he can.
Foster opened with a playful and charming rendition of “The Bare Necessities” from The Jungle Book, putting a subtle country twist on the classic tune. Starting the song at a slower tempo than expected, he then brought it to life with a spirited kick and his trademark grin, transforming the performance into a crowd-pleasing celebration of rhythm and personality.
Judges and fans alike were won over by the balance of fun and musicality, with Luke Bryan telling Foster he had developed a “look and sound that people love.” Carrie Underwood simply called the performance “a good time,” while Lionel Richie praised his magnetic appeal, noting his “likability is off the charts.”
Later in the evening, Foster took a more introspective turn with his second song, offering a tender acoustic take on “Rainbow Connection” from The Muppet Movie. Seated center stage with just his guitar and warm lighting, he delivered a heartfelt and emotionally rich performance that showcased his storytelling ability and vocal restraint.
With the guidance of guest mentor Lin-Manuel Miranda, Foster focused on connecting with the lyrics and making the moment his own rather than mimicking Willie Nelson’s well-known version.
The performance drew some of the most effusive praise of the evening. Richie told him, “I am totally in love with the timbre of your voice. I call it instant identity… that’s what makes an artist.” He added, “The difference between a singer and a stylist is that I know your voice in three notes.” Carrie Underwood echoed the sentiment, suggesting that Foster could go all the way: “If you ain’t real careful, you might win this whole thing.”
Foster’s unique ability to make any song feel personal—whether a jazzy tribute to his Louisiana roots like last week’s “Almost There” or this week’s gentle “Rainbow Connection”—has set him apart as a true artist in the making. With a consistent style, undeniable charm, and a voice judges say they can recognize instantly, John Foster has made a strong case for being crowned the next American Idol.
As the countdown to the finale begins, Foster remains one of the season’s most talked-about contestants—proof that authenticity and heart can go a long way in America’s biggest singing competition.
