American Idol 2025: Who Will Win Season 23? Here’s Our Final Prediction!
Last season, American Idol fans were in sync with the judges when Abi Carter—one of the Platinum Ticket holders—took the crown. It was a rare moment where talent, popularity, and judge support all lined up perfectly.
But this year? Not so much.
In a surprising twist, none of the Platinum Ticket holders—Kolbi Jordan, Canaan James Hill, or Filo—even made it to the Top 5. Filo didn’t crack the Top 10, and Kolbi and Canaan were eliminated shortly after. Clearly, 2025’s journey to the title has taken a different route.
So, Who Will Win American Idol Season 23?
Let’s break down the final three contenders before Sunday’s big finale.
– Jamal Roberts – The Soulful Standout
Jamal Roberts has been a crowd favorite since his audition. The 27-year-old PE teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, is a father of three and a powerhouse on stage. His vocals are smooth, his performances emotional, and he connects deeply with his audience.
Judge Carrie Underwood praised him for making every performance feel personal, saying, “You put yourself in every song and make it look easy.” Lionel Richie added that Jamal knows how to “Jamalarize” a song like no one else.
The only thing working against him? He’s not a country artist—and let’s be honest, country singers have a strong track record of winning Idol. But that hasn’t stopped Jamal from dominating online viewership and building a loyal fanbase.
– John Foster – The Country Underdog Turned Favorite
At just 18, John Foster from Addis, Louisiana, has come a long way. In fact, he almost didn’t even make it to Hollywood—Carrie Underwood had to convince the other judges to give him a shot.
Fast forward to now, and John is a real contender. His country charm, soft vocals, and boy-next-door personality have won over voters, especially on social media polls where he’s consistently at the top.
While he may not have the same performance polish as Jamal, John’s appeal lies in his authenticity. He’s got a Chayce Beckham vibe that Idol fans love—and that could easily push him to the win.
– Breanna Nix – The Dark Horse
Breanna Nix is the surprise finalist this season. A 25-year-old stay-at-home mom from Denton, Texas, Breanna didn’t think she’d even get a Golden Ticket—now she’s one of the last three standing.
Her confidence has grown week by week, and she’s certainly won hearts. However, her online numbers and poll standings suggest she’s a long shot to win it all.
Many fans believe Gabby Samone deserved this spot in the Top 3, and Breanna’s underdog status might hurt her chances. Still, Idol history shows that early exits (hello, Jennifer Hudson!) don’t always mean the end of a star’s journey.
✨ Final Prediction: Who Takes the Crown?
Any of these three could win—it’s truly anyone’s game. But here’s our prediction:
🟩 Who will win: John Foster
🟨 Who should win: Jamal Roberts
John’s country roots and strong fan momentum may carry him over the finish line. But Jamal? He’s the full package—voice, presence, and soul. If America votes based on talent, this should be his moment.
Don’t miss the American Idol Season 23 Grand Finale on Sunday, May 18 at 8 PM ET/PT on ABC. The winner will be revealed live!
👉 Who’s your pick for the crown—John, Jamal, or Breanna? Let us know in the comments!
Let me know if you’d like a version tailored for social media, a headline suggestion, or a thumbnail caption!
