With every performance, Jamal Roberts continues to prove why he’s one of American Idol Season 23’s breakout stars. And during the Top 8 live show, he didn’t just sing—he set the stage on fire with a gutsy, high-energy take on Carrie Underwood’s “Undo It.”
A Bold Song Choice That Paid Off
Taking on a Carrie Underwood anthem is no easy feat—especially in front of Carrie herself, who joined the judging panel for the evening. But Roberts wasn’t fazed. Instead, he leaned into the power and sass of “Undo It,” commanding the stage from the opening beat.
Working closely with guest mentor Miranda Lambert, Roberts made a strategic decision to focus on the emotional arc of the song. Rather than mimic the original arrangement, he let the background singers handle the iconic “uh uh uh” hook so he could add his own gritty adlibs and deliver a more soulful and explosive lead.
A Performance That Had Everyone Talking
Roberts didn’t just perform—he performed. Midway through the number, he broke formation and joined the background singers for a synchronized finish that had the audience on their feet. The judges? Totally sold.
- Luke Bryan tipped his hat—literally—to Carrie.
- Lionel Richie called Roberts “mesmerizing.”
- Carrie Underwood admitted he flubbed a few lyrics, but smiled and said, “Who cares?” The crowd clearly agreed.
Roberts Proves He’s a Contender
This wasn’t Roberts’ first standout moment—but it may have been his boldest. Once again, he reminded everyone watching that he’s not afraid to take risks, and that he knows exactly how to make the most of a live television moment.
Top 8 Results: Who Made It Through
After 22 million votes poured in during the coast-to-coast live show, Ryan Seacrest returned to announce which contestants advanced:
- Jamal Roberts
- John Foster
- Breanna Nix
- Mattie Pruitt
- Josh King
- Gabby Samone
- Slater Nalley
- Thunderstorm Artis
Unfortunately, Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan—both Platinum Ticket winners—were eliminated.
With just a few weeks left until the grand finale on Sunday, May 18, Jamal Roberts is positioning himself as not only a fan favorite but a serious contender for the crown.
