With the American Idol Season 23 finale just days away, emotions are running high and predictions are heating up. After a season filled with raw talent, powerhouse performances, and unforgettable moments, the final three contestants have been revealed: Jamal Roberts, John Foster, and Breanna Nix.
And if you ask judge Luke Bryan, the front-runner has been clear for some time.
“My Gut Says Jamal’s Had the Lead All Year” — Luke Bryan
Following the May 12 live show, Bryan didn’t mince words in a behind-the-scenes interview.
“My gut has told me Jamal has had the lead all year,” Bryan, 48, shared. “He’s been consistent, he’s been commanding… he’s had the reins.”
Bryan praised Roberts’ ability to stay composed under pressure while maintaining a soulful, signature style week after week. However, he didn’t count out the other two finalists.
“Breanna just keeps coming back stronger — she surprises us every week. And John Foster? He’s picking up serious steam. Momentum like his can be a game-changer.”
“It’s Still Anyone’s Game”
The judges are unanimous in one thing: nothing is guaranteed in the finale.
“You can’t afford to lose focus for even a second,” Bryan warned. “This is the music business. Every day counts.”
Fellow judge Lionel Richie added another layer, stressing that talent alone doesn’t decide the outcome.
“It’s not necessarily the best singer who wins,” Richie said. “It’s who the fans connect with — who they’re rooting for, not just as an artist, but as a person.”
In a competition where emotional connection and authenticity matter just as much as vocal range, all three finalists have shown they can win America’s heart.
Carrie Underwood on the Finale Frenzy
Carrie Underwood, the American Idol champion of 2005, offered her perspective on what this week feels like from a contestant’s point of view.
“They’ve had a much shorter season than I did,” she said. “Everything’s moving at lightning speed, and I’m sure they feel like they’re sprinting just to keep up.”
She likened the finale build-up to “star boot camp”:
“This is just a taste of the real world as an artist. They’ll be running nonstop — returning home, performing, promoting — and the pressure only grows from here.”
The Final Countdown
As the finale approaches, the nation is tuning in — not just to witness a winner crowned, but to watch the birth of a new star.
- Jamal Roberts brings a deep well of soul, songwriting strength, and a powerful hometown story from Mississippi.
- John Foster offers authentic country charm, emotional storytelling, and surging grassroots support from Louisiana.
- Breanna Nix stands out as a dark horse with resilience, range, and pop sensibility.
All three have a shot. All three have a story. But only one will take the title of American Idol.
